Changes between Initial Version and Version 1 of Ticket #145, comment 7


Ignore:
Timestamp:
10/26/15 13:07:23 (5 years ago)
Author:
stevehankin
Comment:

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • Ticket #145, comment 7

    initial v1  
    1111Have we side-stepped this concern by making the proposal a "sub-convention"?   Myself, I'd say no to that.  The CF document should not,  itself, knowingly lead to corrupted datasets.
    1212
    13 Are there alternative approaches that may serve the needs of CMIP6 without the brittle linkage problem just outlined?  I believe the answer may be yes and I think John agreed.   A straw man is proposed, above.   What are your thoughts regarding the substance of that straw man?  Could the approach be made satisfactory with modifications?
     13Are there alternative approaches that may serve the needs of CMIP6 without the brittle linkage problem just outlined?  I believe the answer may be yes and I think John agreed.   A straw man is proposed, above; as an entry point see the "external_references" attribute, which is a suggestion of how (borrowing John's words) to "relax the notion of completeness".   What are your thoughts regarding the substance of that straw man?  Could the approach be made satisfactory with modifications?